Episode 219

Would Your FP&A Forecast Survive an Audit? | Norm Osumi
00:00 / 00:00

Would Your FP&A Forecast Survive an Audit? | Norm Osumi

Oct 20, 2026 54:33

A forecast can be useful for running a business and still lack the evidence needed to defend it.

What happens when accounting and FP&A report different revenue numbers for the same month, and the disagreement comes down to how a contract is interpreted? In this episode of FP&A Today, Sarah Schlott welcomes Norm Osumi to explore the judgment calls that sit between financial reporting, business performance and forward-looking forecasts.

Through a SaaS revenue-recognition example, Norm examines why bookings, billings and recognized revenue are not interchangeable, and how implementation fees and sales commissions complicate the picture. The conversation then turns to EBITDA and adjusted EBITDA, where excluding recurring expenses or making aggressive add-backs can change the story a business tells about its performance.

The central question is what happens when an FP&A forecast becomes evidence for an auditor, lender or investor. Norm discusses an auditor requesting five years of purchase orders to substantiate future revenue and explains why assumptions around growth, customer activity and the sales pipeline need to be reasonable and documented. For smaller finance teams, the lesson is not to build more elaborate models. It is to understand which numbers matter, what supports them and when to bring accounting into the conversation.

Key Moments

  • Recognized revenue, bookings and billings serve different purposes. A sound FP&A forecast needs to account for the underlying revenue-recognition rules.

  • SaaS implementation fees and subscriptions can produce different monthly revenue outcomes depending on the contract and performance obligations.

  • Sales commissions raise both operational and accounting questions, especially when bookings, revenue and related costs fall into different periods.

  • Adjusted EBITDA requires judgment. Recurring expenses cannot simply become one-time adjustments because excluding them creates a more attractive result.

  • Forecasts can become part of an audit, valuation or financing process. Assumptions may need to be supported by customer activity, purchase orders and a credible growth pipeline.

  • Smaller finance teams still benefit from documenting the handful of assumptions that materially drive their forecasts.

  • Repeated misses against publicly communicated financial projections can damage management's credibility.

  • FP&A and accounting need shared definitions, clear communication and a process for challenging assumptions before numbers reach external stakeholders.

Timestamps

05:42 - Why FP&A and accounting can recognize different revenue amounts

09:04 - Bookings versus billings versus recognized revenue

12:21 - How smaller companies should approach accounting for sales commissions

16:46 - EBITDA and the judgment behind adjustments

21:14 - GAAP, non-GAAP and adjusted EBITDA reporting

28:08 - When an FP&A forecast becomes audit evidence

33:33 - What auditors look for in forecast assumptions

36:45 - Documenting assumptions that support revenue projections

42:15 - Does forecast accuracy actually matter?

45:13 - Rapid fire with Norm Osumi

Earn CPE Credit

If you would like to earn CPE credit for listening to the show, visit:

https://earmarkcpe.com/fpa

Download the app, take a short quiz, and get your CPE certificate.

Further Reading/Listening

Related FP&A Today episode:

The $100M Revenue Mistake Everyone Missed, with Devon Coombs

https://www.devoncoombs.com/

Related Episodes

From Coca-Cola and Heineken to steervalue: An FP&A Framework That Works for Any Size Organization | Pieter van Loosbroek
00:00 / 00:00

FP&A creates the most value when it moves beyond reactive reporting and helps businesses make better decisions. But making that shift requires more than asking finance teams to be strategic.

Why do so many FP&A professionals spend their time producing reports instead of influencing business decisions? In this episode of FP&A Today, Sarah Schlott speaks with Pieter van Loosbroek, Founder and Managing Partner of steervalue, about how organizations can redesign FP&A to become more effective business partners.

Drawing on his experience at Coca-Cola and Heineken, Pieter explains how traditional reporting cycles can prevent finance professionals from supporting the decisions that matter most. At Coca-Cola, working closely with commercial teams revealed opportunities to improve route-to-market strategies, pricing decisions, and customer relationships. At Heineken, Pieter helped develop a more structured approach to FP&A, defining its purpose, processes, responsibilities, and performance expectations across a complex global organization.

Pieter introduces his five-pillar FP&A framework, covering data and accounting, performance evaluation, forecasting and scenarios, planning and targeting, and resource allocation. He explains how the same principles can apply to organizations of different sizes and maturity levels without creating unnecessary complexity. The conversation also explores how to overcome limited capacity, secure leadership support, improve business partnering, and establish the process foundations needed before introducing AI and automation.

KEY MOMENTS

  • Move beyond reactive reporting. FP&A teams can become trapped in recurring requests, forecasts, and reporting cycles, leaving too little time to influence important business decisions.

  • Understand the business beyond the spreadsheet. At Coca-Cola, Pieter worked alongside commercial teams to evaluate distribution strategies and customer relationships, demonstrating why finance professionals need operational knowledge to create value.

  • Define what FP&A should accomplish. At Heineken, establishing a clear FP&A vision and documenting processes helped create a more consistent approach across different operating companies.

  • Use maturity assessments to guide improvement. Organizations don't need to transform everything at once. Understanding the current position, desired outcomes, and realistic next steps makes change more manageable.

  • Build FP&A around five fundamental questions. Pieter's framework connects historical performance, analysis, forecasting, planning, and resource allocation to the decisions finance needs to support.

  • Adapt the framework to your organization's size. Smaller businesses can apply the same FP&A principles as large multinationals without adopting unnecessary corporate complexity.

  • Establish a mandate for proactive business partnering. Clear expectations and leadership support help FP&A move from responding to requests toward participating in business decisions.

  • Start with one important decision. Rather than attempting a complete transformation, identify a consequential business decision, document its drivers and metrics, and build a practical improvement plan around it.

  • Get the fundamentals right before introducing AI. Automation and agentic AI depend on clear, documented processes. Technology alone cannot compensate for poorly defined workflows.

  • Avoid overengineering. More complexity doesn't always produce better insights. Financial analysis needs to be understandable, timely, and useful for decision-making.

TIMESTAMPS

00:00 - Breaking free from the FP&A reporting hamster wheel

03:03 - Coca-Cola: When finance couldn't find time for business partnering

15:03 - Heineken: Redesigning FP&A processes across a global organization

22:24 - Using maturity assessments to improve FP&A step by step

27:38 - The five pillars of Pieter's FP&A framework

30:20 - Why the framework works for organizations of different sizes

42:01 - The barriers to FP&A transformation: Capacity, mandate, and decision infrastructure

46:37 - Starting with one consequential business decision

49:48 - Three practical takeaways: FP&A purpose, business drivers, and documented processes

60:48 - Why overengineering can reduce the value of financial insights

EARN CPE CREDIT

Earn CPE credit for listening to the show. Visit Earmark CPE, download the app, take a short quiz, and get your certificate.

FP&A TODAY WEEKLY COLUMN

Sign up for Sarah Schlott's weekly FP&A Today column. Each week she shares what she's learned interviewing the best FP&A leaders and CFOs, plus behind-the-scenes content and the hottest takes not shared anywhere else.

Sign up for Sarah Schlott's weekly FP&A Today column

FURTHER READING / LISTENING

About Pieter van Loosbroek

Pieter van Loosbroek is the Founder and Managing Partner of steervalue. His career includes finance and commercial roles at Coca-Cola and global FP&A process leadership at Heineken. Through steervalue, he helps organizations strengthen their FP&A processes, operating models, and business decision-making.

Pieter van Loosbroek – LinkedIn

steervalue – Official Website

AdamI – AI Partner

FP&A Trends – Finance at a Crossroad: Why FP&A Must Transform Now and How AI Is Rewriting the Rules

Related FP&A Today Episode

Sales vs. Finance: What Great Business Partnership Really Looks Like

An earlier conversation hosted by Glenn Hopper exploring how finance and sales can work together to improve forecasting, commercial decisions, and business performance.

The Human Skills AI Can't Replace in Finance | Becky Glover
00:00 / 00:00

As AI takes on more analytical work, the next advantage for FP&A is knowing how to adapt, build trust, and work with people.

What happens to finance professionals when AI can handle more of the analysis? In this episode of FP&A Today, Sarah Schlott speaks with Becky Glover, a multi-award-winning CFO, founder, board member, and co-founder of Connexion Career Collective, about the skills finance teams need as technology changes how they work. Becky introduces RQ — the resilience and relationship skills that complement analytical ability (IQ) and emotional intelligence (EQ).

Becky draws on her experience introducing automation into accounts payable and running a two-person wine business to explain why small experiments build confidence. She also explores how FP&A professionals can navigate changing strategies and forecasts, create trust across teams, and listen to the problems their colleagues are facing. Her message is not to resist AI, but to use it for what technology does well while developing the human relationships and judgment that help businesses move forward.

KEY MOMENTS

  • Experiment before attempting a full transformation. Becky began with practical accounts-payable tasks, such as invoice capture, purchase-order matching, and approvals, and expanded from there.

  • Let automation create room for strategic work. Removing repetitive tasks allowed Becky to work across more of the business instead of staying in the weeds.

  • IQ and EQ are not the whole picture. Becky uses RQ to describe resilience and sustained relationships — qualities that become especially useful when circumstances change.

  • Resilience matters when the forecast changes again. New assumptions and shifting strategies demand adaptability, not just an accurate spreadsheet.

  • Build trust by listening first. Colleagues are more likely to collaborate when they feel heard and supported, particularly during difficult change.

  • Do not let junior colleagues miss out on learning. As technology takes on more routine work, experienced finance professionals still need to share process knowledge and mentor others.

  • Keep the annual budget for the conversation it creates. Becky sees value in bringing non-finance leaders together to understand strategy, trade-offs, and costs.

  • Ask what is keeping your colleagues awake at night. Becky recommends listening to the answer without rushing to offer a solution, because operational problems can affect the wider business.

TIMESTAMPS

00:00 - AI, RQ, and the human advantage

03:00 - Why finance professionals feel behind on AI

08:10 - Starting AI adoption with accounts-payable automation

14:19 - What Becky learned from running a two-person wine business

20:44 - IQ, EQ, and RQ: explaining resilience and relationships

28:28 - Handling changing forecasts and building resilience

30:10 - Why finance leaders need to listen and build trust

38:14 - What AI cannot replace about working with people

42:36 - Rapid fire: Excel, annual budgets, and version control

48:11 - A question every finance leader should ask their team

EARN CPE CREDIT

Earn CPE credit for listening to the show. Visit Earmark CPE, download the app, take a short quiz, and get your certificate.

FURTHER READING / LISTENING

About Becky Glover

Becky Glover is a multi-award-winning CFO, two-time founder, board member, advisor, and speaker. She co-founded Connexion Career Collective, a community focused on meaningful relationships and professional growth.

Becky Glover – Official Website

Becky Glover – LinkedIn

Connexion Career Collective

Copy the Architecture. Not the Bureaucracy. | Eric Lin
00:00 / 00:00

Big-company FP&A has valuable lessons - but its processes are often responses to problems your business may not have.

What should an FP&A team borrow from Google, Netflix, and Roku, and what should it leave behind? In this episode of FP&A Today, Sarah Schlott speaks with Eric Lin, former Head of FP&A for Roku TV, about the difference between copying big-tech finance processes and building the decision-making foundations your business actually needs.

Eric describes his career shift from analysis to influence to decision architecture: shared metrics, explicit assumptions, clear ownership, driver-based forecasts, and an operating cadence that helps leaders respond when circumstances change. He explains why finance professionals need to understand their business deeply, prioritize the questions that affect decisions, and make recurring reporting efficient enough to leave time for forward-looking analysis.

The conversation also explores three layers of AI use in FP&A, the risks of automating weak data and inconsistent metrics, and what Eric would rebuild first if every finance report disappeared. His warning to smaller teams is simple: enterprise processes are often scar tissue from past failures. Copy the foundations that matter, not the bureaucracy built around someone else's problems.

Key Moments

  • FP&A should improve decisions, not only produce analysis. Eric traces the evolution from analytical rigor to influence and ultimately decision architecture.

  • Give every important decision a foundation. Shared metric definitions, explicit assumptions, data ownership, decision rights, and operating cadence matter more than a sophisticated planning platform.

  • Understand the business before diving into the model. Go deepest on the assumptions and analyses that could change a meaningful decision; delegate routine work to a capable team.

  • Make recurring reporting efficient. Close, board preparation, and earnings reporting are necessary, but they should not consume the time needed to understand the next quarter.

  • Use AI to support better judgment. Production and diagnostic work can become faster, but AI-driven decision support requires trusted data, governance, and human ownership of trade-offs.

  • Do not inherit big-company bureaucracy by default. Ask what failure a control or process was designed to prevent and whether that risk is material to your business.

  • Start with cash and the drivers behind results. If the reports disappeared, Eric would restore cash-flow visibility first; he also values business KPIs that explain the P&L.

  • Build FP&A around the decisions that matter. Start with a decision inventory, reliable actuals, business drivers, and a driver-based forecast before layering on specialization and technology.

Timestamps

02:08 - Why FP&A needs to evolve from analysis to decision architecture

05:40 - How junior analysts become more valuable business partners

08:10 - Knowing when to dive deep into the numbers

12:19 - Making reporting efficient to protect forward-looking work

16:54 - The three layers of AI in FP&A and why governance matters

23:39 - What to copy from big tech - and what bureaucracy to avoid

29:30 - If every report disappeared, start with cash flow

31:37 - KPIs versus the P&L: understanding what drives performance

35:07 - How Eric would build an FP&A team from scratch

42:31 - The Monday test: does your finance work drive impact?


Earn CPE Credit

If you would like to earn CPE credit for listening to the show, visit:

https://earmarkcpe.com/fpa

Download the app, take a short quiz, and get your CPE certificate.


Further Reading / Listening

About Eric Lin

Eric Lin, former Head of FP&A for Roku TV, led the financial strategy and cross-functional business case for the Board-approved launch of Roku-branded TVs and helped scale the new business from $0 to $200 million in first-year revenue.

Connect with Eric on LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ericlin/

Become a Partner

Drive Business Performance With Datarails

Drive Business Performance With Datarails

Drive Business Performance With Datarails

Drive Business Performance With Datarails

Drive Business Performance With Datarails

Drive Business Performance With Datarails